Airbnb to ban hosts from using indoor security cameras in rental properties

Airbnb said Monday that it’s banning the use of indoor security cameras in listings on its site around the world by the end of next month.

The San Francisco-based online rental platform says it is seeking to “simplify” its security-camera policy while prioritizing privacy.

“These changes were made in consultation with our guests, hosts and privacy experts, and we’ll continue to seek feedback to help ensure our policies work for our global community,” Juniper Downs, Airbnb’s head of community policy and partnerships, said in a prepared statement.

Airbnb had allowed the use of indoor security cameras in common areas, as long as the locations of the cameras were disclosed on the listings page.

Under the new policy, hosts will still be allowed to use doorbell cameras and noise-decibel monitors, which are only allowed in common spaces, as long as the location and presence of the devices are disclosed.

Airbnb expects the policy update to impact a small number of hosts because the majority of its listings do not report having indoor security cameras.

The policy change will take effect April 30. In its fourth-quarter earnings report last month, Airbnb said its bookings and revenue rose, and the company said demand remained strong.

WATCH | Toronto landlord finds condo listed on Airbnb by someone who wasn’t her tenant:

Landlord finds condo listed on Airbnb. But not by her tenant

A Toronto landlord found her condo listed on Airbnb by someone who wasn’t her tenant. She blames the city’s lax rules around licensing short-term rentals and is calling for changes to regulations.

Privacy over security

Airbnb’s policy update is a good step in the right direction, said Ann Cavoukian, a former Ontario privacy commissioner.

While she understands property owners want to ensure their homes or rental units are secure, she said that doesn’t supersede a guest’s right to privacy.

“Cameras pose hidden risks all the time,” she told CBC News in a phone interview from Scottsdale, Ariz.

It’s not only a matter of a guest having their Airbnb host listening in on their personal conversations or watching their private activities, she said, but there is also the concern of a third party gaining access to that camera’s feeds and recordings.

A portrait of a woman with glasses gazing into the camera.
Former Ontario privacy commissioner Ann Cavoukian is pleased with Airbnb’s policy change regarding indoor security cameras and is encouraging other vacation rental companies to follow suit if they don’t already have similar rules in place. (Dave MacIntosh/CBC)

“It’s amazing how brilliant the hackers are today, and they’re gaining access to video, to audio, to all kinds of information that they’re not supposed to have access to,” she said.

“The risks you take in putting in security cameras or any of these devices are significant because you can’t just assume that those people who put the camera in [are] gonna be the only ones seeing it.”

If a host has concerns about the security of their property, she said they should interview their potential guests before they consider renting to them. The same goes for guests who have concerns about their privacy when choosing a rental, she said.

LISTEN | How much are short-term rentals to blame for rising rents?:

Front Burner20:34Will the Airbnb crackdown lower rents?

With high living costs and rising rents, governments are going after Airbnb and Vrbo. British Columbia is the newest, along with New York and Quebec. How much are short-term rentals to blame? Will this action be enough? David Wachsmuth, a researcher and professor at the School of Urban Planning at McGill University, joins us. For transcripts of Front Burner, please visit: Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next weekday.

A hidden problem to deal with

The new policy won’t be able to do much to prevent hidden cameras from being installed in an Airbnb property, said Cavoukian.

Hidden cameras are “strictly prohibited” under Airbnb’s policiesbut cases of guests uncovering them have been reported.

She urges anyone who finds such a device in their vacation rental to remove it and to notify police.

Unfortunately, he said, the consequences for coveringtly recording someone are often minimal.

She encourages guests to ask their potential hosts about any and all cameras on the property and get assurances that they’re not being recorded.

Although there are no guarantees, he said doing so may make the owners reconsider using such devices.

“Privacy forms the foundation of our freedom,” she said. “We cannot give up on it just because there are all these technological advances.”

WATCH | Airbnb hosts, long-term renters face off over short-term rentals:

Airbnb hosts vs. renters: a tough conversation about the housing crisis

Many Canadians are struggling to find housing, but are short-term rentals part of the problem? The National brings together landlords who have turned to Airbnb and long-term renters who feel like they’re being crushed by soaring rent prices and the shrinking availability of rental properties.

Tags: ,